Method Article
The acute liver failure animal model developed in the current study presents a feasible alternative for the study of potential therapies. The current model employs the combined effect of physical and drug-induced hepatic injury and provides a suitable time window to study the potential of novel therapies.
Acute liver failure (ALF) is a clinical condition caused by various etiologies resulting in the loss of metabolic, biochemical, synthesizing, and detoxifying functions of the liver. In most irreversible liver damage cases, orthotropic liver transplant (OLT) remains the only available treatment. To study the therapeutic potential of a treatment for ALF, its prior testing in an animal model of ALF is essential. In the current study, an ALF model in rats was developed by combining 70% partial hepatectomy (PHx) and injections of acetaminophen (APAP) that provides a therapeutic window of 48 h. The median and left lateral lobes of the liver were removed to excise 70% of the liver mass and APAP was given 24 h postsurgically for 2 days. Survival in ALF-induced animals was found to be severely decreased. The development of ALF was confirmed by altered serum levels of the enzymes alanine amino transferase (ALT), aspartate amino transferase (AST), alkaline phosphatase (ALP); changes in prothrombin time (PT); and assessment of the international normalized ratio (INR). Study of the gene expression profile by qPCR revealed an increase in expression levels of genes involved in apoptosis, inflammation, and in the progression of liver injury. Diffused degeneration of hepatocytes and infiltration of immune cells was observed by histological evaluation. The reversibility of ALF was confirmed by the restoration of survival and serum levels of ALT, AST, and ALP after intrasplenic transplantation of syngeneic healthy rat hepatocytes. This model presents a reliable alternative to the available ALF animal models to study the pathophysiology of ALF as well as to evaluate the potential of a novel therapy for ALF. The use of two different approaches also makes it possible to study the combined effect of physical and drug-induced liver injury. The reproducibility and feasibility of current procedure is an added benefit of the model.
Acute liver failure (ALF) is defined by the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases as rapid development of acute liver injury without any prior signs of damage and is characterized by severe impairment of the synthetic, metabolic, and detoxifying functions of the liver1. ALF differs from chronic liver failure where the failure occurs as a result of liver injury caused over a long period of time and from acute chronic liver failure (ACLF), where abrupt liver damage takes place as a result of chronic liver diseases2,3,4. The only available cure for ALF is orthotopic liver transplant (OLT), or death may occur. Due to the shortage of liver donors, the rate of mortality in patients suffering from ALF is very high.
To study the potential of alternative therapeutic approaches and to better understand the pathophysiology of ALF, animal models that can reflect the ALF occurring in human beings are needed. Many of the already available ALF animal models have several shortcomings. Acetaminophen (APAP) effects are difficult to reproduce but have the closest similarities in terms of temporal, clinical, biochemical, and pathological parameters. APAP- induced animal models frequently encounter problems due to the presence of methemoglobinemia caused by the oxidation of hemoglobin by APAP and its intermediates5,6,7. Another problem is the lack of reproducibility reflected by unpredictable dose responses and the time of death. The ALF animal models produced using carbon tetra chloride (CCl4) have poor reproducibility8,9,10,11. Concavalin A (Con A) and lipoplysaccharide (LPS)-induced ALF animal models do not reflect the clinical pattern of the human disease, though they have advantages in the study of cellular mechanisms involved in autoimmune liver diseases and in the study of sepsis respectively12,13,14,15. Similarly, thioacetamide (TAA) also requires biotransformation to an active metabolite thioacetamide sulfoxide and shows species variation16,17,18,19. D-galactosamine (D-Gal) produces some biochemical, metabolic, and physiological changes similar to ALF but is not able to reflect the whole ALF pathological condition20,21,22,23. There have been very few attempts to combine two or more of these methods to develop an ALF model that is able to reflect the ALF syndrome in a better manner13. Therefore, further studies are required to develop a model that can reflect the disease parameters, has better reproducibility, and provides enough time to study the effects of a therapeutic intervention.
In the current study, an alternative ALF model in rats has been created by combining the effects of partial hepatectomy (PHx) and lower doses of a hepatotoxic reagent. APAP has a well-established role in causing liver injury5,24,25. It is a widely used analgesic and is toxic to the liver at supratherapeutic doses by forming toxic metabolites. APAP is the cause of many deaths in developed countries. Physical injury caused by partial hepatectomy initiates activation of various processes involved in inflammation as well as liver regeneration. Injection of the hepatotoxic agent APAP causes a hostile environment in the liver, preventing the proliferation of hepatocytes. This reduces the stress period on the animal, which when combined with smaller doses of hepatotoxin, leads to better reproducibility of the procedure. Therefore, using this model, a combinatory effect of two types of liver injuries has been studied. To characterize the developed ALF animal model, physiological and biochemical parameters have been studied. Successful reversibility of ALF was confirmed by transplantation of syngeneic healthy rat hepatocytes.
The procedure described below has been approved by the Institutional Animal Ethics Committee of National Institute of Immunology, New Delhi. The serial reference number of the approval is IAEC#355/14.
1. Preparation
2. Preoperative procedures
3. Partial hepatectomy (PHx) to remove 70% of the mass of the liver
NOTE: Perform the entire surgical procedure under a sterile environment in a laminar flow hood. Use only sterile surgical instruments to minimize the risk of infection postsurgically. Removal of 70% of the liver mass, named 70% partial hepatectomy (70% PHx), was performed as described by C. Mitchell and H. Willenbring, 200827.
4. Postoperative care in animals
5. Injection of drug in partially hepatectomized animals to induce liver failure
6. Transplantation of healthy hepatocytes in ALF animal models
NOTE: To study the reversibility of ALF in rats, transplant healthy syngeneic rat hepatocytes intrasplenically in the ALF-induced animals along with the 1st dose of APAP. In the current study, to provide ample time to the transplanted cells for homing and engraftment, the transplantation was done just after giving the 1st dose of APAP. Rat hepatocytes are isolated by a protocol first published by Berry and Friends et al.28 and later adapted in various other studies29,30,31 with some modifications. For intrasplenic transplantation of cells in the ALF animal model, follow the steps mentioned below.
7. Characterization of ALF development
Survival percentage in animal models of ALF
The optimum dose of APAP to cause ALF in combination with 70% PHx was standardized as 750 mg/kg body weight. The treatment regimen started 24 h after 70% PHx, when the animals had completely recovered from surgery, and consisted of two APAP doses at 24 h intervals. Mortality was observed at the rate of 80% after the administration of the second dose of APAP, 48 h post-surgery. The survival percentage was analyzed and plotted via the Kaplan-Meier method (Figure 1). The reproducibility in time of death and time period provided by this model makes it a suitable candidate for studying a therapeutic intervention against ALF.
Four groups of animals were considered for the study: Group 1 (control group, only saline treatment), Group 2 (only APAP at 750 mg/kg body weight), Group 3 (saline treatment with 70% PHx) and Group 4 (APAP at 750 mg/kg body weight with 70% PHx). Three animals each were included in all the groups and two representative images are included from each group. Animals from all four groups were euthanized 2 h after the administration of the 2nd dose of the respective treatment. Liver samples taken from all four groups showed distinct morphology from each other. Group 1 showed the reddish-brown morphology of a healthy rodent liver. Liver samples of Group 2 showed no apparent signs of damage at a morphological level and showed similar appearance to the healthy livers of Group 1. Liver samples taken from Groups 3 and 4 did not appear healthy and had discoloration and a patchy appearance. The discoloration corresponds to the damage in the liver tissue and was more apparent in Group 4. Representative data are presented in Figure 2.
The extent of liver injury was determined by checking the serum levels of ALT, AST, and ALP enzymes36,37,38. The levels of ALT, AST, and ALP showed marked differences among the four groups corresponding to the extent of liver damage. Group 4 showed a significant increase in the AST and ALP levels compared to Group 1 (Figure 3).
To compare the gene expression profile in control and ALF-induced groups, q-PCR analysis of genes involved in cell death (Bax2, Caspase3, Fas) in liver tissue samples was performed35,39. These were found to be upregulated in Group 3 in comparison to control Group 1, whereas no difference was seen in Group 2 and Group 4. Genes which are known to be overexpressed in response to liver injury (Mcp1 and Mmp2)33,40 were found to be upregulated in all three groups in comparison to control Group 1. Mmp9 was upregulated in Groups 3 and 4 whereas Group 2 showed no marked difference from control Group 1. Expression levels of Timp1 and Timp234 were found to be higher in Group 3 but showed no marked overexpression in Group 4 (Figure 4).
Genes involved in inflammation of the liver (Tnfa, IL1a, Tgfbr1, and IL1b)41,42,43,44 were found to be overexpressed in Group 3 in comparison to control Group 1 but their expression level was decreased in Group 4. ALR is overexpressed in liver tissue after the induction of liver injury. The downstream cascades of this gene help in liver regeneration. RIP1 protein is necessary in APAP-induced toxicity. ALR and RIP1 were found to be upregulated in Groups 2 and 3 in comparison to control Group 1, whereas their levels remain similar or lower in Group 4. Alpha smooth muscle actin (aSMA), a marker of excessive ECM deposition that further leads to fibrosis, was found to be upregulated in Group 3 and 4 in comparison to control Group 1 (Figure 4). Gene expression data suggests that the above-mentioned biomarkers of inflammation and cell death that are known to be overexpressed during liver injury are upregulated in liver tissue samples of animals in which ALF was-induced by proposed method, thus confirming the occurrence of liver injury at the molecular level.
Hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining
Hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining was done to assess the severity of liver injury by observing the extent of hepatocyte degeneration. The liver tissue sections stained with H&E were subjected to blind analysis by a third party. In the 70% partial hepatectomy group vesicular fatty degeneration was observed and in the acetaminophen group periportal inflammation and necrosis was seen along with mild sinusoidal dilatation. Vesicular fatty degeneration was observed mostly in the ALF group (Figure 5).
Prothrombin time and blood glucose levels
Prothrombin Time (PT) is a parameter that depends on the activity of the liver-synthesized tissue thromboplastin and is used to characterize the efficiency of the blood coagulation mechanism45. Generally, an increase in PT is observed in the conditions of liver-related diseases. PT was found to be significantly higher in the ALF-induced group in comparison to the control group. The international normalized ratio (INR)45 was also found to be higher, representing a defect in the mechanism of blood coagulation as a result of inefficient liver physiology (Figure 6).
Evaluation of survival after cell healthy syngeneic rat hepatocytes transplantation
An important criterion of an ALF model is the reversibility of liver failure in the presence of a therapeutic intervention. In the current study, 10 million healthy syngeneic rat hepatocytes were transplanted instrasplenically to observe the effect of cell transplant therapy on liver failure. The appropriate number of cells to be transplanted was determined by observing the reversibility of liver failure after transplantation of different cell numbers (data not shown). Cells were transplanted after administration of the 1st dose of APAP, and survival was found to be restored in animals after the transplantation of cells (Figure 7). The serum levels of enzymes ALT, AST, and ALP were found to be normalized after 10 days of cell transplantation (Figure 8).
Figure 1: Survival percentage in the ALF-induced group. Kaplan-Meier Survival Curve showing the survival percentage of animals after induction of ALF with the combination of 70% PHx and APAP dose (750 mg/kg body weight). Time 0 h denotes the time of 70% PHx. The 1st and 2nd doses of APAP were administered 24 and 48 h postsurgically (n = 12, total animals). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Representative images of liver morphology in the four different groups included in the study. Image panels A–D show the morphology of the livers of different groups after being euthanized 2 h after the 2nd dose of the respective treatment. (A) The liver morphology of control Group 1 in which only saline was given. (B) The liver morphology of Group 2 in which only APAP was given at the dose of 750 mg/kg body weight. (C) The liver morphology of Group 3 in which saline was given following 70% PHx. (D) The liver morphology in Group 4 in which APAP was given following 70% PHx at the dose similar to Group 3 (n = 3 animals per group). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: A comparison of the biochemical profile of serum in the different groups. Bar graphs represent the mean value of ALT, AST, and ALP in serum samples of the four groups included in the study. Serum was collected 2 h after the 2nd dose of the respective treatment. Error bars = S.E.M; *** = p < 0.001; * = p < 0.05; n = 3. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Gene expression profile of liver tissue samples. Bar graphs represent the relative quantification of the mRNA expression of various genes involved in inflammation and cell death in the four groups subjected to different treatments. All genes were normalized against the expression of control Gapdh. Error bar = standard error mean of the three different samples (n = 3). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Histological study of liver tissue samples. Representative hematoxylin and eosin staining images of liver tissue samples from the four groups included in the study, as observed under 200x magnification in bright field microscopy. There were mostly normal hepatocytes in control Group 1 with mild periportal infiltration (green arrows). In Group 3 (70% partial hepatectomy) vesicular fatty degeneration was observed (white arrows) and in the acetaminophen Group 2 periportal inflammation (red arrows) and necrosis were seen along with mild sinusoidal dilatation (yellow arrows). Macrovesicular fatty degeneration was mostly observed in the ALF Group 4 (orange arrows). Scale bar = 50 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Comparison of prothrombin time (PT) and international normalized ratio (INR). (A) Comparison of PT between control Group 1 (saline injection post 70% PHx) and ALF-induced Group 4 (APAP injection post 70% PHx). Blood was collected 2 h after the 2nd dose of the respective treatment and time (in seconds) required for fibrin clot formation is shown on the Y axis (**** = p < 0.0001, n = 5). (B) The INR in the ALF-induced Group 4 in comparison to control Group 1. The mean value of INR in Group 4 was found to be 2.28, which falls in the Warfarin-induced anti coagulating effect (n = 5). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7: Survival percentage in ALF-induced group after cell transplant. Kaplan-Meier survival curve showing the survival percentage after healthy hepatocyte transplantation in the ALF-induced Group 4 in comparison to control Group 1 (n = 5). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 8: Serum biochemical profile of ALF-induced animals after cell transplant. Serum levels of enzymes ALT, AST, and ALP 10 days after cell transplantation in comparison with the serum levels of ALF-induced animals euthanized after a 2nd dose of APAP administration. Error bar = standard error of mean of five different samples; **** = p < 0.0001; ** = p > 0.01; n = 5. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
The development of an appropriate animal model for ALF is paramount for the better understanding of pathogenesis and progression of ALF. A well characterized ALF animal model also provides the opportunity for the development and trial of new therapeutic approaches against ALF. Many attempts have been made to develop a clinically relevant model of ALF6,12,21,23,46,47,48. Most of these studies either utilize surgical procedures or induce liver injury by hepatotoxic chemicals.
It is difficult to create an ALF model by PHx alone because PHx would not reflect the pathology of ALF due to the absence of inflammation caused by the necrotic and apoptotic tissues. At therapeutic doses, APAP is metabolized completely by the processes of glucoronidation and sulphation. At higher doses, when these pathways are saturated, APAP is metabolized by cytochrome p450 enzymes which are primarily synthesized by hepatocytes, resulting in the formation of a toxic intermediate, NAPQI (N-acetyl-p-benzoquinone imine). Under normal conditions NAPQI is neutralized by the glutathione (GSH) reserves of cells, whereas at supratherapeutic doses it causes oxidative stress in hepatocytes, resulting in hepatocyte death4,24,25,46. Hence, by combining the physiological effects of 70% PHx and APAP-induced liver injury, an ALF rat model was created in the current study. A smaller therapeutic window reduces the stress period on the animal. When combined with smaller doses of APAP, this leads to better reproducibility of the procedure.
The dose of APAP was selected to provide a suitable therapeutic window during which a therapeutic intervention can be given to the animal (i.e., within 48 h of the 1st dose and 24 h of 2nd dose). Within 24 h after the 2nd dose of APAP, 100% mortality was observed. However, the time of death within this period was variable for each animal. Hence, for the purpose of studying the development of ALF, the animals were euthanized at a standard time point of 2 h after the 2nd dose of APAP.
The time of therapeutic intervention can be decided depending upon the individual study and the type of therapy being studied, which in the current study was transplantation of syngeneic rat hepatocytes just after the 1st dose of APAP, allowing the cells enough time to home and engraft. In the current model, transplantation of at least 10 million cells is required for a successful rescue from ALF.
To ensure the success of the surgical procedure, a few important points should be considered. It is recommended to use different types of anesthetics in different surgical procedures. To perform partial hepatectomy, a cocktail of ketamine-xylazine should be used in the recommended doses because it gives ample time to complete the surgical procedure. During cell transplant, inhalable anesthesia isoflurane should be used because it reduces the physical stress on ALF-induced animals.
In conclusion, due to a uniform mortality rate and a convenient therapeutic window, an APAP and 70% PHx combined model was used to study the reversibility of ALF by cell transplantation. To assess the reversibility of ALF, 10 million healthy syngeneic rat hepatocytes were transplanted intrasplenically in the ALF-induced animals. After transplantation, the survival percentage was found to be increased in ALF-induced animals. Improvement in serum levels of ALT, AST, and ALP was also observed in animals after cell transplant, suggesting the restoration of liver metabolism. This ALF animal model presents an alternative to evaluate the therapeutic potential of cells bridging the gap between acute liver failure and liver transplantation. It also provides the opportunity to study liver damage caused by physical injury and hepatotoxic agent.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by the core grant received from the Department of Biotechnology, Government of India to National Institute of Immunology, New Delhi.
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
Acetaminophen (Biocetamol) | EG Pharmaceuticals | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Alkaline Phosphatase Kit (DEA) | Coral Clinical System, India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Automated analyser | Tulip, Alto Santracruz, India | Screen Maaster 3000 | Biochemical analyser for liver functional test |
Betadine (Povidon-Iodine Solution) | Win-Medicare; India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Biological safety cabinet (Class I) | Kartos international; India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Bright Field Microscope | Olympus, Japan | LX51 | |
Cefotaxime (Taxim®) | AlKem; India | cefotaxime sodium injection, No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Cell Strainer | Sigma; US | CLS431752 | |
Collagenase Type I | Gibco by Life Technologies | 17100-017 | |
Cotton Buds | Pure Swabs Pvt Ltd; India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Drape Sheet | JSD Surgicals, Delhi, India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
DPX Mountant | Sigma; US | 6522 | |
Eosin Y solution, alcoholic | Sigma; US | HT110132 | |
Forceps | Major Surgicals; India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Gas Anesthesia System | Ugo Basile; Italy | 211000 | |
Glucose | Himedia, India | GRM077 | |
Hair removing cream (Veet®) | Reckitt Benckiser, India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Hematoxylin Solution, Mayer's | Sigma; US | MHS16 | |
Heparin sodium salt | Himedia; India | RM554 | |
Hyaluronidase From Sheep Testes | Sigma; US | H6254 | |
I.V. Cannula (Plusflon) | Mediplus, India | Ref 1732411420 | |
Insulin Syringes | BD; US | REF 303060 | |
Isoflurane (Forane®) | Asecia Queenborough | No B506 | Inhalation Anaesthetic |
Ketamine (Ketamax®) | Troikaa Pharmaceuticals Ltd. | Ketamine hydrochloride IP, No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Meloxicam (Melonex®) | Intas Pharmaceuticals Ltd; India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Micro needle holders straight & curved | Mercian; England | BS-13-8 | |
Micro needle holders straight & curved | Mercian; England | BS-13-8 | |
Microtome | Histo-Line Laboratories, Italy | MRS3500 | |
Nylon Thread | Mighty; India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Paraformaldehyde | Himedia; India | GRM 3660 | |
Percoll® | GE Healthcare | 17-0891-01 | |
Refresh Tears/Eyemist Gel | Allergan India Private Limited/Sun Pharma, India | P3060 | No specific Catalog Number |
RPMI | Himedia; India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Scalpel | Major Surgicals; India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Scissors | Major Surgicals; India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
SGOT (ASAT) KIT | Coral Clinical System, India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
SGPT (ALAT) KIT | Coral Clinical System, India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Shandon Cryotome E Cryostat | Thermo Electron Corporation; US | No specific Catalog Number | |
Sucrose | Sigma; US | S0389 | |
Surgical Blade No. 22 | La Medcare, India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Surgical Board | Locally made | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Surgical White Tape | 3M India; India | 1530-1 | Micropore Surgical Tape |
Sutures | Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson, India | NW 5047 | |
Syringes (1ml, 26 G) | Dispo Van; India | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
Trimmer (Clipper) | Philips | NL9206AD-4 DRACHTEN QT9005 | |
Weighing Machine | Braun | No specific Catalog Number (Local Procurement) | |
William's E Media | Himedia; India | AT125 | |
Xylazine (Xylaxin®) | Indian Immunologicals Limited | Sedative, Pre-Anaesthetic, Analgesic and muscle relaxant |
Request permission to reuse the text or figures of this JoVE article
Request PermissionThis article has been published
Video Coming Soon
Copyright © 2025 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved