* These authors contributed equally
Pediatric small round blue cell tumors are an intriguing and challenging collection of neoplasms. Therefore, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and professional knowledge of pediatric tumors can be extremely valuable in surgical pathology. Here, we present a protocol to perform TEM for diagnosing neuroblastoma, one of the most common solid tumors in childhood.
Pediatric small round blue cell tumors (PSRBCT) are an intriguing and challenging collection of neoplasms. Light microscopy of small round blue cell tumors identifies small round cells. They harbor a generally hyperchromatic nucleus and relatively scanty basophilic cytoplasm. Pediatric small round blue cell tumors include several entities. Usually, they incorporate Wilms tumor, neuroblastoma, rhabdomyosarcoma, Ewing sarcoma, retinoblastoma, lymphoma, and small cell osteosarcoma, among others. Even using immunohistochemistry, the differential diagnosis of these neoplasms may be controversial at light microscopy. A faint staining or an ambiguous background can deter pathologists from making the proper diagnostic decision. In addition, molecular biology may provide an overwhelming amount of data challenging to distinguish them, and some translocations may be seen in more than one category. Thus, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) can be extremely valuable. Here we emphasize the modern protocol for TEM data of the neuroblastoma. Tumor cells with tangles of cytoplasmic processes containing neurosecretory granules can diagnose neuroblastoma.
The work of a pathologist may be pretty challenging both in clinical diagnostics and research fields. The evolution of light microscopy in the 18th and 19th century was remarkable. The power of an electron microscope relies primarily on the wavelength of the electrons, which is shorter than light1,2,3. Before the advent of the polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies and their application in immunohistochemistry, TEM played an influential role in diagnosing small round blue cell tumors.
Starting with the 90's of the last century, the immunohistochemical approach has substituted the morphologic tool in diagnostics4. Currently, there are thousands of new polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies directed to antigens of the small round blue cell tumor group4,6,7,8. In the last decade of the highly prolific 20th century and the first decade of the beginning of the 21st century, molecular biology, including fluorescence in situ hybridization, from genomic probes through next-generation sequencing, seems to have superseded the significant application role of immunohistochemistry in several laboratories4. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in the United States of America, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) of Canada, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), or similar governmental bodies in other countries do not always approve molecular biology protocols9. It seems that there is a lot of information quite challenging to insert in a pathology report that can be used for therapeutic purposes, and the oculate choice of a well-funded and running laboratory information system is critical10. In the meantime, immunohistochemistry has revealed numerous pitfalls, with epithelial tumors showing mesenchymal markers and vice versa11. The epithelial-mesenchymal transition has confused some borders in pathology groups12,13. In the last few years, it has become evident that electron microscopy flourished in several labs worldwide14. In particular, the tissue specimens' turnaround time has decreased from weeks to only 3 days or even less using several protocols approaching the staining with monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies4,10.
Moreover, applying an electronic camera coupled to the electron microscope helped provide the pathologists with a rapid image, which is versatile in different operating systems. Finally, some antibodies, even after antigen retrieval, are challenging to be revealed in some areas of necrosis or autophagy/ischemia-related changes. At the same time, electron microscopy in safe hands can still deliver excellent results and hints for the correct classification of unknown pathologic tumors15.
The pediatric small round blue cell tumor group includes several tumors, mainly neuroblastoma, Wilms tumor or nephroblastoma, rhabdomyosarcoma, and Ewing sarcoma. The molecular biology data relative to the pediatric group of small round blue cell tumors can be overwhelming because of the techniques applied. The small round blue cells may not differ much on routine stains (hematoxylin and eosin staining), and some tumors may have aberrant immunophenotypical features. Advances in molecular biology have been enormous since the discovery of TEM. In the group of small round blue cell tumors, some neoplasms may be more frequently encountered than others, but they need to be considered. Although the papillary renal cell carcinoma is not essentially a small round blue cell tumor but features papillae mostly, it may show some round cell areas that may need to be distinct from other well-known small round blue cell tumors (e.g., Wilms tumor) using several ancillary techniques16. Ultimately, metanephric stromal tumors may also need to be taken into differential diagnosis17. The rhabdoid tumor is a particularly malignant pediatric tumor distinct in the renal and extra-renal subtype18.
Neuroblastoma is one of the most common solid malignancies in infancy and childhood. Neuroblastoma cells are the malignant cells of this solid tumor that arise insidiously from derivatives of the primordial neural crest. Its diagnosis and differential diagnosis may be difficult. Its natural biology has seen remarkable advances in the last couple of decades. The forkhead family of transcription factors is characterized by a distinct "forkhead" domain (FOXO3/FKHRL1). These transcription factors function as a trigger for apoptosis (programmed cell death) through the expression of genes necessary for cell death. FOXO3/FKHRL1 is activated by 5-aza-2-deoxycytidine and induces silenced caspase-8, and this complex plays a crucial role in neuroblastoma. Nuclear FOXO3 predicts adverse clinical outcomes and promotes tumor angiogenesis in neuroblastoma7,19. Despite the molecular pathology advances, the Shimada classification remains the standard of practice for any pathologist and pediatric oncologist. It is critical in differentiating between favorable and unfavorable histology20,21,22,23.
The rationale for developing a straightforward protocol for the electron microscopy of tumors suspicious of neuroblastoma is linked to the feasibility and solidity of the ultrastructural examination of the tissue specimen. It is rarely altered by problems commonly encountered using immunohistochemistry. The rationale and protocol have been the basis of several textbooks and scientific contributions to pediatric pathology and electron microscopy4,24,25. This protocol spans the experience of three decades of the author and will focus on a few PSRBCT, emphasizing the personal experience and the literature review.
All procedures performed in studies involving human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki Declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards. The electron microscopy study is part of the normal routine for microscopic investigation of the samples received for diagnostic purposes and does not require approval by the Bioethics Committee. This study is retrospective and respects the complete anonymity of the samples.
1. TEM protocol for FFPE (formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded) retrieval and glutaraldehyde-fixed tissue specimens
2. TEM protocol for scanning and photographing the specimens
The distinctive TEM Features of the neuroblastoma are displayed here. Here we will illustrate the distinctive TEM features of the neuroblastoma.
Neuroblastoma is one of the most common solid malignancies in infancy and childhood. Neuroblastoma cells are the malignant cells of this solid tumor that arise insidiously from derivatives of the primordial neural crest. This histogenesis explains some biochemical and morphological characteristics of this blue tumor. However, neuroblastomas' deterministic cyto- and histopathological features can specifically fluctuate according to the variable degree of differentiation. Therefore, its diagnosis and differential diagnosis may be difficult. The distinction of neuroblastoma to ganglion cell-like elements is shown by an increasing amount of cellular cytoplasm with the development of a cytoplasmic process and an alteration of the nuclear image (Figure 1A-D). Nuclear enlargement and a visible nucleolus are characteristic of neuroblastoma differentiation. Differentiation to Schwann cell-like elements may also be noticed. The electron microscopic investigation reveals neurosecretory granules (average diameter 100 nm) constantly present with or without neurite-like cytoplasmic projections containing microtubules and thin intermediate filaments26. The paucity of glycogen characterizes neuroblastoma, and if it is rarely seen, it never builds aggregates. The degree of differentiation distinguishes the ultrastructure of neuroblastoma. Neurosecretory or catecholamine granules are characteristic of this neoplasm, with a diameter of about 150 nm. The neurosecretory granules need to be differentiated from desmosome-like structures. Neurosecretory granules can be seen close to intracytoplasmic filaments (neurofilaments). The cell processes are often plump and cylindrical and are commonly referred to as neurites (axons and dendrites). Some cell processes contain mitochondria, which are critical for the movement of the neoplastic cell. Neurites contain microtubules but also may have swollen mitochondria. In the event of a poorly differentiated neuroblastoma, some features are more often to be found. They include a more significant irregularity of nuclear morphology, numerous mitoses and apoptotic figures, paucity of microtubules and cell processes, contrasting with the almost constant presence of neurofilaments, scarcity of neurites, which contain more often mitochondria than microtubules, no or very few synaptic junctions, no glycogen, areas of numerous polyribosomes, and paucity of neurosecretory granules. Neurosecretory granules are critical to differentiate neuroblastoma from other PSRBCT, including embryonal rhabdomyosarcoma, eosinophilic granuloma, small cell osteosarcoma, and reticulum cell sarcoma, which may cause diagnostic challenges because of the presence of cytoplasmic granularity.
Figure 1: TEM of Neuroblastoma. (A-C) Neuroblastoma cells of a poorly differentiated type with a high nucleus-to-cytoplasm ratio and a few organelles. The chromatin is scattered in the nucleus but also concentrated at the periphery close to the nuclear membrane. A nucleolus is visible in a nucleus in the upper-right corner (scale bar: 2 µm). (D) Neuroblastoma cells with neurosecretory granules exhibiting a characteristic double membrane (scale bar: 200 nm). Red arrows point to the nucleoli, blue arrows reveal heterochromatin, orange arrows detect euchromatin, green arrows focus on mitochondria, and yellow arrows point to vesicles resembling the normal presynaptic terminals. However, the vesicles in neuroblastoma are larger and more irregular than the classic presynaptic terminals. Finally, the black arrows reveal numerous dense-core neurosecretory granules. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
In this narrative review with associated protocol, we highlighted the distinctive ultrastructural features of the neuroblastoma. In the end, we suggest that electron microscopy is far from a "dead" or ancient technique, postulating the discovery of a new role if combined with single-cell omics technologies. This contribution would like to emphasize the never ancient role of electron microscopy in pediatric pathology4,27. The critical steps, the modifications and troubleshooting of the technique, and the limitations are detailed below.
There are a few critical steps to this protocol. First, it is essential to cut the desired area for electron microscopy. The edge of the diamond must be adjusted to face the face of the block as close as possible. This requires a very steady hand. Care should be taken while picking up the floating section with the copper grids.
Modifications and troubleshooting of the technique include a few aspects that need to be taken into account. Every sample is different with qualities, such as density and nature, which are variable. Given the nature and density of the material, not all tissue specimens are cut in the same way. For instance, some neuroblastoma specimens may be undifferentiated or poorly differentiated, while others may reveal a high degree of differentiation and a variable degree of calcifications. Occasionally, multiple sections have to be cut to get a few good ones to be processed further. It is crucial to avoid any kind of vibrations: breathing, table, compressors from the EM scopes. If shattering on the sections is encountered, it may be key to tighten the UCM screws. If scratches are seen on the sections, change the diamond knife to be used for cutting. Sometimes, cutting artifacts are only seen at the final step. If cutting artifacts are detected under the electron microscope, ultra-thin sections have to be recut after identifying the cause of the artifact.
TEM has obvious limitations, and the window of observation is even smaller than the view captured using conventional light microscopy. The desired area for the electron microscopy cannot be bigger than a 1 mm square. Sometimes, a bigger area would benefit the screening, but it is impossible to cut. It will not fit on the copper grid, it will damage the diamond knife, and the quality of the section will definitely be inferior. Some choices have to be made, and the most important structure or area at the time of the screening has to be chosen. The cutting speed cannot be increased; it will cause cutting artifacts on the sections. The 1 mm/sec remains critical.
In addition to the classic features listed above (e.g., neurosecretory granules), the ultrastructure of mitochondria in neuroblastoma cells examined by TEM often shows remarkable levels of mitophagy, a mitochondrial quality control selective cellular mechanism enabling the degradation of mitochondria, which are considered by the cells to be damaged and/or superfluous28,29. As a result, the mitochondria harbor swelling, cristae rupturing, and cristae disappearance. In fact, Radogna et al. found efficient mitophagy as the critical mechanism leading to the failure of activation of the pathway of programmatic cell death that increased resistance of SK-N-AS, a neuroblastoma cell line with enhanced synthesis of Insulin-like growth factor II (IFG-II) and IGF-II RNA and harboring type I IGF receptors to UNBS1450, a hemi-synthetic cardenolide belonging to the cardiac steroid glycoside family, triggering necroptosis at somewhat higher doses30.
Particularly relevant to the differential diagnosis is the role of TEM for Ewing sarcoma. The Ewing sarcoma is considered equivalent to peripheral neuroectodermal cell tumor, although some debate has been spent in the past31,32,33. Practically, in the Ewing sarcoma primitive cells, abundant cytoplasmic glycogen, poorly developed cell junctions, and no neural features are the main characteristics. There is a striking similarity in the peripheral neuroectodermal tumor to Ewing sarcoma on electron microscopy. In fact, both tumors are considered the same entity and are treated with the same therapeutic protocols in both SIOP (International Society of Pediatric Oncology) and COG (Children's Oncology Group) as well as the UKCCSG (United Kingdom Children Cancer Study Group) because they share the same chromosomal translocation. However, in PNET, some neural features exist, including neurosecretory granules that are virtually absent in Ewing sarcoma. This specification also reflects the immunohistochemical phenotype. There is positivity for at least one or two neural markers, e.g., neuron-specific enolase, S-100, synaptophysin, or neurofilaments. Franchi et al. studied the ES-PNET31. In most cases, neoplastic cells had the typical ultrastructure, including firmly packed, poorly differentiated cells, oval to polygonal shape. These cells contain a round or oval nucleus with finely dispersed chromatin and one or two nucleoli. In the cytoplasm, tiny organelles mirroring these neoplastic cells' poor differentiation. However, the close attention to detail may reveal the presence of mitochondria, a few rough endoplasmic reticulum structures (the so-called cisternae), sporadic lysosomes, and free ribosomes. Glycogen accumulation may be easily detected. Glycogen can be seen as either dispersed or pooled. Intermediate filaments are often observed in both the cytoplasm and cytoplasmic processes of the tumor cells. Microtubules are not seen. Rudimentary junctions may be detected in about half of the cases about the cell connections. These structures are made of well-developed desmosomes with tonofilaments if the junctions are identified. Some accumulation of basement membrane-like material and collagen fibrils in the extracellular matrix can be recognized. Dense core granules with a diameter similar to the granules seen in neuroblastoma can be observed. Like the immunohistochemical investigations of the previous authors31, well-differentiated neoplasms tend to occur outside of the skeleton, while poorly differentiated tumors arise more often in bone than in soft tissue.
In conclusion, TEM is an outstanding technology that can have enormous potential in the future and is far from dead in medicine. The introduction of molecular biology techniques with the most recent advancement with next-generation sequencing highlights the inconsistency of a continuum in diagnostics but a Kangaroo-like wave of progress. Introducing new methods should not dissuade pathologists from using electron microscopy consistently because both the immunohistochemistry and molecular techniques can be fallacious. Some immunohistochemical patterns and genetic abnormalities are not tumor-specific and may correlate poorly with histology. To our knowledge, TEM remains a robust, valid, and reproducible method in pathology and medicine. TEM is an ancillary tool for investigating small round blue cell tumors and is a solid proof of the immunohistochemical result. Applying TEM consistently in a modern facility can provide a high interindividual agreement score, high validity, and efficient reliability. In the near future, molecular biologists may search for competent and valid laboratories of electron microscopy that may answer specific questions at the ultrastructural level. In particular, we see a new perspective and application of TEM in molecular biologies, such as the coupling of TEM with experiments aiming to understand some current single-cell research.
The first author receives royalties from the following publishers: Springer (https://link-springer-com.remotexs.ntu.edu.sg/book/10.1007/978-3-662-59169-7; ISBN: 978-3-662-59169-7) and Nova (https://novapublishers.com/shop/science-culture-and-politics-despair-and-hopes-in-the-time-of-a-pandemic/; ISBN: 978-1-53619-816-4). All royalties go to pediatric charities.
We acknowledged the expertise and generous support of Dr. Richard Vriend, formerly an Alberta Health Services employee at the University of Alberta Hospital, and Steven Joy (1972-2019), also formerly an Alberta Health Services employee at the University of Alberta Hospital. We dedicate this work to the memory of Mr. Joy, a senior technologist expert in ultrastructural investigations who tragically and prematurely passed away a few years ago. Mr. Joy was a pillar for most electron microscopy studies in Alberta, Canada. Our thoughts and prayers for him and his family. We are also indebted to Ms. Lesley Burnet for her help and advice. Dr. C. Sergi's research has been funded by the generosity of the Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario, Ottawa, Ontario, and the Stollery Children's Hospital Foundation and supporters of the Lois Hole Hospital for Women through the Women and Children's Health Research Institute (WCHRI, Grant ID #: 2096), Natural Science Foundation of Hubei Province for Hubei University of Technology (100-Talent Grant for Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts Total Funding: Digital PCR and NGS-based diagnosis for infection and oncology, 2017-2022), Österreichische Krebshilfe Tyrol (Krebsgesellschaft Tirol, Austrian Tyrolean Cancer Research Institute, 2007 and 2009 - "DMBTI and cholangiocellular carcinomas" and "Hsp70 and HSPBP1 in carcinomas of the pancreas"), Austrian Research Fund (Fonds zur Förderung der wissenschaftlichen Forschung, FWF, Grant ID L313-B13), Canadian Foundation for Women's Health ("Early Fetal Heart-RES0000928"), Cancer Research Society (von Willebrand factor gene expression in cancer cells), Canadian Institutes of Health Research (Omega-3 Fatty Acids for Treatment of Intestinal Failure Associated Liver Disease: A Translational Research Study, 2011-2014, CIHR 232514), and the Saudi Cultural Bureau, Ottawa, Canada. The funders had no role in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
Acetone, ACS Reagent | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 10014 | Reagent as established by the American Chemical Society (ACS Reagent). |
Automated tissue processor | Electron Microscopy Sciences | L12600 | LYNX II Automated Tissue Processor for Histology and Microscopy. |
Digital camera software | Gatan | L12600 | Digital Micrograph |
Spurr's resin | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 14300 | Embedding resin. It provides excellent penetration for embedding tissues and rapid infiltration. The blocks have excellent trimming and sectioning qualities, while thin sections reveal tough qualities under the electron beam. |
Ethyl Alcohol | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 15058 | 100% Ethyl alcohol with molecular sieve, 50% and 70%. |
Glutaraldehyde, 25% EM Grade Aqueous in Serum Vial | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 16214 | 2.5% gluteraldehyde in 0.1 M cacodylate buffer, pH 7.2-7.4 made from 25% gluteraldehyde, primary fixative for TEM tissue specimens. |
Osmium tetroxide | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 19110 | Second fixative during TEM tissue processing used as OsO4 in distilled water |
Polyethylene capsules | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 70021 | Flat Bottom Embedding Capsules, Size 00 |
Scintillator | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 82010 | Phillip Quad Detector |
Single Edge Razor Blade | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 71952-10 | Blade for Clean Rm., 10/Disp. . |
Sodium Cacodylate Buffer | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 11655 | Sodium Cacodylate Buffer, 0.4M, pH 7.2, prepared from Sodium Cacodylate Trihydrate |
Tannic Acid, Reagent, A.C.S., EM Grade | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 21700 | Reagent as established by the American Chemical Society (ACS Reagent). |
Transmission Electron Microscope (1) | Hitachi | Hitachi 7100 | We use it at the HV 75 setting |
Transmission Electron Microscope (2) | JEOL | JEM-1010 | We use it at the HV 38 setting |
Toluene | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 22030 | Reagent as established by the American Chemical Society (ACS Reagent) |
Ultracut microtome | Leica | 11865766 | Ultramicrotome |
Uranyl acetate | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 22400 | Uranyless, substitute for uranyl acetate |
Request permission to reuse the text or figures of this JoVE article
Request PermissionThis article has been published
Video Coming Soon
Copyright © 2025 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved