Method Article
Earthworms are a novel invertebrate in vivo bench-top model for vasculature studies. We present techniques and equipment that allow efficient surgery and microinjection into the earthworm vasculature. Surgical protocols, microinjection techniques and the procedure for producing custom-made micropipettes are described.
Although vertebrates are indispensable to biomedical research, studies are often limited by factors such as cost, lengthy internal review, and ethical considerations. We present the earthworm as an alternative, low-cost, invertebrate applicable to certain preliminary vasculature studies. Due to the surgical availability of the earthworm's dorsal vessels, ventral vessels, and five pairs of pseudo hearts, earthworms are readily accessible, offer low-cost maintenance, and require administration of only small doses of a given compound. The earthworm model provides a simple closed vascular circulatory system with a hemoglobin structure similar to human blood. A protocol is provided for anaesthetizing the earthworms and performing surgical incisions to expose relevant blood vessels. Micropipettes for compound administration are formed by heating and pulling glass with a pipette puller and using a beveling system to create a micron-scale fine needle tip. The tips are then used with a micropositioner and microinjector to inject arbitrary compounds into the vascular system of an earthworm, repeatably, with the availability of large sample sizes and small compound volumes. Details on the intricacies of injection procedure are provided. The small vessel size of the earthworm is challenging, particularly in the case of the ventral vessel; however, mastery of the techniques presented offers high repeatability as a low-cost solution, making studies of very large sample size practical.
The earthworm has been used as an important bioindicator and bioassay for previous scientific applications1,2,3,4,5,6; it is an ideal organism for assessing biological risks from hazardous and toxic waste in terrestrial environments for in situ and bioaccumulation studies, such as biocides (insecticides) in soil and adverse ecotoxicological effects7,8,9,10. Additionally, due to bioprospecting, the earthworm is an alternative source of fibrinolytic, anti-coagulative, anti-microbial, and anti-cancer molecules11,12; to the point that a team in 1991 extracted and purified lumbricine from the earthworm skin and placed on mammary tumors of SHN mice, which led to tumor growth inhibition13. The earthworm is also a pedagogically useful animal model, as it can be used to expose students to surgery and to understanding the anatomy of a specimen; from studying blood circulation to electrophysiology14,15.
In our own research we have examined the response of the vessels of live earthworms to high intensity ultrasound18. We found that vessel rupture in the worm occurred under conditions similar to those that we associated in rupture damage in human micro-vessels. Our ongoing work involves injection of microbubbles into the earthworm vasculature. Microbubbles are composed of a heavy gas encased by a lipid, albumin or polymer shell, these agents can be used as image contrast agents as well as vehicles for targeted drug delivery.
This novel protocol is relevant to any study that would benefit from intravenous (IV) injection of a compound that could utilize the earthworm's natural bioindicators. The approach is based around IV microinjection into one of several possible entry points, including any of the earthworm's five-pair pseudo hearts, the dorsal vessel, and the ventral vessel. The procedure involves an elaborate surgical incision to expose the vessels, followed by a micro-positioner-controlled injection. This is achieved using custom micropipettes constructed specifically for earthworm vascular microinjection. These micropipettes allow precision targeting of vessels as small as a 90 µm diameter ventral vessel.
This protocol is designed to improve upon earlier micro-pipetting techniques, including a 1948 study for the extraction of earthworm blood and urine16. As seen in Figure S1, the setup for this extraction can be difficult, and, as stated by the author, can take up to one hour or longer. A similar method was developed in 1970, but the author experienced multiple broken tips while injecting fluids into the giant fibers of the earthworm17. In the present method described below, extraction of blood is a matter of seconds to minutes and is relevant to both the injection of compounds and extraction of earthworm fluids. In this specific case, we injected contrast agents, microbubbles.
1. Micropipette preparation: pulling glass and beveling tip
2. Microinjector calibration with beveled tips
3. Earthworm surgery preparation to expose specific earthworm vasculature of interest
4. Compound Administration into Earthworm Vasculature
The following representative results are based on a set of specific parameters that include the settings used to pull the glass pipette, the pipette opening size formed from a given beveling angle, and the pressure and time of the microinjections. In Figure 1, a schematic of the flow is displayed representing the process from start to finish.
Based on the pipette puller parameters selected, the following tip would emerge from the pull (Figure 2). It is noted that that the RAMP value may change due to the type of glass and even the placement of the filament. If the parameters are acceptable, the resulting tip will be strong, with a long taper for beveling. If the tip is broken from pulling, then the puller must be readjusted.
For beveling the micropipette, six beveling angles were tested to determine the optimal angle, to assess the general ease of beveling, and to examine how angle affected tip opening size. The optimal angle for our beveling criteria was determined to be 35° as it provides a sharp tip, it is strong enough to penetrate the vessel without breakage, and it is highly reproducible. Generally, the smaller the angle, the sharper the tip becomes as shown in Figure 3. Another angle of interest was 30°, which is sharper, but 35° was chosen, due to its reproducibility. As shown in Figure 4, the angle of the micromanipulator changes both the shape and the opening size of the tip. It is shown in this figure that the most accurate and consistent beveling occurs with an angle between 30° and 40°. A supplementary table (Table S1) was created based on the ease of beveling, though it is important to note that, person-to-person, beveling techniques vary, and thus tips vary. It is further noted that unsuccessful bevels can occur when the micromanipulator is lowered too quickly or when the glass becomes too brittle, leading to tip breakage.
For a given tip size, a calibration must be performed prior to compound injections. The injection volume dependent upon tip size as well as microinjection pressure, and the injection time. For example, in Figure 5, representative volume dispenses are graphed for 24.4 µm tips. Data reveals an approximately linear relationship between volume dispensed and pressure for fixed injection times. Similar custom calibration data should be determined for specific tip designs.
During microvascular injection, visual inspection is necessary to confirm a successful injection of a given product. The best visible marker is the dilution of the blood. As shown in the Supplemental Video and Figure 6, the blood becomes clearer as it is diluted, and this is a sign of successful injection. It is critical that the micropipette does not penetrate the vessel too deeply and that the microinjection is not made at an angle greater than 15° from the vessel, otherwise when the pipette is pulled out, the compound of interest will bleed out of its vasculature, due to large wounds. A successful injection and pull will result in minimal bleeding upon removal.
Figure 1: Flow of the Overall Method. For microinjection of the earthworm vasculature, first the pipette needs to be pulled to achieve a micro opening at the tip. Then the micropipette tip is beveled to achieve a sharp needle tip. Once the opening is achieved, the micropipette is calibrated for the proper volume dispensed. Once calibrated, injections to the vasculature can be accomplished. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Successful Pulled Micropipette. Based on the parameters used in the protocol, this tip would emerge after pulling. (A) Demonstrates the pipette immediately after being pulled. (B) An up-close image of the same pipette pulled. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Micropipette Tip Beveling Angle Profiles. Six angles were tested for beveling. Decreasing angle from 45° to 20°, the sharpness and tip opening increases. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Tip opening narrows over increasing angle. Six angles were tested to see how angle affects the tip opening size. Tip opening size decreases as the beveling angle increases. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Calibration for Volume Administration. A 24.4 µm tip size opening was used for its representative results to represent data using the specific parameters for time and pressure. With increasing pressure, the volume dispensed increases, and with decreasing time, the volume dispensed decreases. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Injection into Ventral Vessel. A visual for successful injection is demonstrated with the dilution of blood as an indicator. A supplemental video is accompanied with this panel. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure S1: Set-up for blood and urine extraction of Earthworm. Please click here to download this File.
Figure S2: Standard deviations from Figure 4. Depending on angle, the standard deviation changes. 35° holds a lower standard deviation, thus more consistent in beveling and the tip breaks less. 30° was also good with 35° as shown in Table S1. Please click here to download this File.
Figure S3: Demonstrates the survival of the earthworm after surgery and using liquid band aid to close the earthworm. Please click here to download this File.
Table S1: Descriptive table for Ease of Beveling. Three modes were used to describe the ease of beveling ranging from easy, to moderate and difficult. It is noted that 15° was tested but it was too small of an angle to produce a micropipette tip that did not chip. Please click here to download this Table.
Supplemental Video. Please click here to download this Video.
While the earthworm is in 10% ethanol, particularly if the earthworm is of older age, there may be unwanted effects for exposure times greater than 30 minutes; the intestines will start to deteriorate, and when the earthworm is surgically opened, its internal intestines spread out. Therefore, it is encouraged to use young to mid-aged earthworms. During the process of cutting through the skin of the earthworm, it is imperative that a full scissor cut is not made, meaning the investigator must cut only halfway and keep pushing the scissors forward until reaching the final point. When pinning down the earthworm, be careful not to stretch out the earthworm or pull too hard. This could cause the vessel to rupture, which leads to bleeding. After each injection, check if the micropipette is clogged by dispensing any fluids that may be inside the micropipette, especially to remove blood from the tip before performing another injection. In addition to observing the tip for clogging, after each injection look at the tip of the micropipette to check for tip breakage. The tip of the micropipette could also be broken, leaving the tip in place to avoid any blood loss. It is important to carefully observe the vessel tissue during microinjections. When the micropipette first comes into contact with the vessel, the vessel tissue will cling onto the micropipette tip. Once the tip has successfully penetrated the vessel, the vessel tissue can be seen rapidly sliding into the tip and it will be felt on the micromanipulator as well. After a successful injection, it is important to pull the micropipette out carefully as the micropipette could end up going deeper into the tissue or creating a bigger wound on the injection site, and this could lead to the compound administration leaking out of the vessel. Typically, successful injections occurred when the vessel diameter was 90 µm or larger, but this can be improved by narrowing micropipette tip sizes by the investigators. The earthworm is consistently kept moist with water to avoid the earthworm becoming dehydrated but saline solution is recommended.
Earthworm Survival Studies
Earthworm survival experiments were conducted to give insight into how long the earthworms can survive after experimentation. After the worms were immersed in a 10% ethanol solution and then surgically cut and injected, just as they were during the experiments, 27 worms were "sewn back up" via liquid band-aid solution and observed up to 48 hours post-experiment. At 12 hours post-operation, approximately 67% of the worms were still alive. At 24 hours post-op, about 48% of the worms were still alive. At 36 hours post-op, about 44% of the worms were still alive. Lastly, at 48 hours post-op, about 22% of the worms were still alive. The results from these experiments show that the majority of worms can survive for an entire 12-hour day after having undergone experimental surgery and injection, and a large number of worms can survive for even longer than that (Figure S3). This presents an opportunity for each worm to be monitored for 24-hour-long studies, if desired.
Earthworm Laboratory Care
Earthworms, Canadian nightcrawlers, were store-bought from Windsor Wholesale Bait and were delivered as 500 large earthworms in a Styrofoam box (35w x 38l x 30d cm) and kept in the refrigerator, as individual worms were removed and used for experiments. As noted in the earthworm preparation protocol steps, no more than 10 earthworms were used at once due to evaporation of the earthworm, which can lead to dehydration16. In addition, exposure of earthworms to light was limited, since they contain light-sensitive cells on their skin; light exposure longer than two hours can lead to death. Immediately upon arrival, the shipping container soil was changed, and earthworms were allowed to rest for a 24-hour wait period before being used for the experiments. This ensured the earthworms were reenergized and no longer fatigued due to shipping. At this point, experimentation on the earthworm can begin.
Earthworms have an unknown lifespan, but they can be kept alive in a laboratory setting for long periods when they are monitored every day and given the right nutrients. Every two weeks, new soil should be added into the container to provide more nutrients for the earthworm. The earthworm is a deep burrowing invertebrate, anecic, and will build burrows as deep as 180 cm (6ft), so there must be at least 1 foot of soil in the container for 500 earthworms. At the bottom of the container, old newspaper can be added, as this is where some of the earthworms will create their homes. Once the soil has been changed, it is recommended to check for smell and spot any injured or dead earthworms. Do not leave dead or injured earthworms in the container, as they will contaminate the soil and create more deaths within your earthworm colony.
Future Applications
In this protocol, the preparation and procedure for performing high-throughput blood experiments using the earthworm is presented. While restricted to the circulatory system, the injection methods described here could potentially be expanded to studies involving the nervous system, as the earthworm's nerve cord is in parallel to the ventral vessel. For example, previous research using the earthworm have been studied for neuromodulation and vessel-rupture studies from therapeutic ultrasound applications18,19. With this new set-up, further in-depth ultrasound + microbubbles studies could be conducted to expand on neuromodulation and vessel rupture research.
In addition, the coelomic cavity in the earthworm could be utilized to study the immune system, because the fluid that resides in the coelomic cavity mediates most, if not all, immune responses. The earthworm is unique in that only two fluids exist in the animal, each contained within separate cavities, the blood in vessels and coelomic fluid in the coelomic cavity. This separation of fluids allows for specific types of research in two cavities. For example, the coelomic fluid is replete with numerous coelomocytes, whose immune functions share characteristics with coelomocytes of most other animal models. Investigations of phagocytes and other similar cells that can destroy cell targets can be performed in the earthworm, and the earthworm likely has many additional research applications that could be used as an alternative invertebrate model.
While the earthworm lacks the complexity to model many aspects of the human anatomical and physiological system, microinjection offers a contained circulatory system containing blood strikingly similar to human blood in terms of hemoglobin structure. In applications where small blood volumes are acceptable, the earthworm offers a low cost, readily available testing platform, exempt from Institutional Animal Care and Use Committees. As a result, testing on earthworms with various compounds can be done repeatedly and in sample sizes likely to far exceed what would be practical using standard laboratory vertebrate animals.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was funded by the NSF-FDA Scholar-in-Residence Fellowship (NSF-FDA SIR, #1641221), US Food and Drug Administration Office Chief Scientist Challenge Grant (FDA OCS), National Science Foundation Integrative Graduate Education and Research Traineeship (NSF IGERT, #1144646) and supported by the Office of Science and Engineering Laboratories (OSEL) at the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
3M Vetbond Tissue Adhesive | 3M Vetbond | 084-1469SB | 3mL bottle vet adhesive - liquid band-aide |
40x Stereo Microscope | Sutter Instrument Co. | BV-10-D | Not needed, can add on other scopes |
500 Large Worms | Windsor Wholesale Bait | 500 Large | |
Beveler pedestal oil | Sutter Instrument Co. | 008 | |
Blades | Ted Pella, Inc | 121-2 | |
Borosilicate Glass with Filament | Sutter Instrument Co. | BF150-86-10 | |
Camera | AmScope | MU500 | |
Camera | AmScope | MU1803-CK | 8MP USB3.0 Microscope Digital Camera |
Electrode Impedance Meter | Sutter Instrument Co. | BV-10-C | |
Ethanol | Sigma Aldrich | E7023-1L | Pure ethanol |
Filament | Sutter Instrument Co. | FT315B | trough filament |
Grinding Plate | Sutter Instrument Co. | 104D | Fine Plate |
Hospital Grade Saline | Baxter Healthcare Corporation | 2F7124 | 0.9% Sodium Chloride Irrigation |
Joystick Micromanipulator | Narishige | MN-151 | |
KimWipes Kimtech Science | Kimberly-Clark Professional | 34155 | |
Leafgro | LeafGro | 589252 | 1.5-cu. ft. |
Metal Hub Needle | Hamilton | 91024 | Luer Lock Metal Needle |
Micro Vessel Clips | WPI | 501779-G | |
Microinjector | TriTech Research | MINJ-D | |
Micropiette Puller Model P-97 | Sutter Instrument Co. | P-97 | |
Micropipette Beveler | Sutter Instrument Co. | BV-10-B | |
Microscope | AmScope | SM-8TPW2-144S | 3.5X-225X Simul-Focal Articulating Microcope |
Needle Holder | TriTech Research | MINJ-4 | |
NeverWet | Rust-Oleum | NeverWet | |
Pyrex Glass | Corning | 08747A | Fisher Manufacturer |
Stainless Micro-Ruler | Ted Pella, Inc | 13635 | Micro-Ruler mounted on a Handle, 10mm scale, with lines at 0.01mm intervals |
Surgical Grips | Ted Pella, Inc | 53073 | Forceps, Hemostat |
Surgical scissors | Ted Pella, Inc | 1320 | Fine Iris Scissors, Straight |
U.S.P. Mineral Oil Lubricant Laxative | Swan | Mineral Oil |
Request permission to reuse the text or figures of this JoVE article
Request PermissionThis article has been published
Video Coming Soon
Copyright © 2025 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved