This protocol shows that hyperbaric oxygen can enhance the proliferation inhibition and apoptosis of U251 glioma cells treated with X-ray irradiation by blocking the cells in the G2/M phase. This improves the radiosensitivity of human glioma cell lines.
The aim of this study was to explore the use of hyperbaric oxygen to enhance the radiosensitivity of human glioma cells. Sub-cultured U251 human glioma cells were randomly divided into four groups: an untreated control group, cells treated with hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) only, cells treated with X-ray irradiation (X-ray) only, and cells treated with both HBO and X-ray. Cell morphology, cell proliferation activity, cell cycle distribution, and apoptosis were observed in these groups to evaluate the role of HBO in improving the radiosensitivity of glioma cells. With the increase in X-ray doses (0 Gy, 2 Gy, 4 Gy, 6 Gy, 8 Gy), the survival fraction (SF) of glioma cells gradually decreased.
Significantly lower SF was observed for the cells treated with the HBO and X-ray together than in the X-ray group for each dose (all P < 0.05). The proliferation inhibition was significantly higher in the HBO combined with X-ray group than in the X-ray group for each dose (all P < 0.05) for the U251 cell line. The percentage of G2/M phase cells was significantly higher in the HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) group (26.70% ± 2.46%) and the HBO group (22.36% ± 0.91%) than in the control group (11.56% ± 2.01%) and X-ray (2 Gy) group (10.35% ± 2.69%) (all P < 0.05). U251 cell apoptosis was significantly higher in the HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) group than in the HBO group, the X-ray (2 Gy) group, and the control group (all P < 0.05). We conclude that HBO can enhance the proliferation inhibition and apoptosis of glioma U251 cells by blocking glioma cells in the G2/M phase and improve the radiosensitivity of U251 glioma cells.
Glioma is a primary intracranial tumor that originates from central nervous system glial cells1. The current treatment strategy for glioma is surgery combined with radiotherapy and chemotherapy. Postoperative radiotherapy for glioma can provide survival benefits (grade I evidence), and early postoperative radiotherapy can effectively prolong patient survival (grade II evidence)2. For higher-grade gliomas (grade III or IV), especially highly malignant and invasive glioblastoma (grade III evidence)3, postoperative radiotherapy should be performed as early as possible (<6 weeks). However, despite early intervention, glioma still has a high recurrence rate and poor prognosis after comprehensive treatment. These outcomes are mainly associated with the low radiosensitivity of glioma. Factors related to tumor radiosensitivity include the inherent radiosensitivity of tumor cells, hypoxic or non-hypoxic tumor cells, the proportion of hypoxic tumor cells, and the capacity of peritumoral tissue to repair radiation damage4.
Among these factors, hypoxic or non-hypoxic tumor cells and the proportion of hypoxic tumor cells have important effects on tumor radiosensitivity. Hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) can improve tissue oxygen storage by increasing tissue oxygen tension and blood oxygen diffusion. HBO may also produce a series of beneficial biochemical, cytological, and physiological effects5. For example, HBO has a marked reparative effect on radiotherapy-induced radiation damage. Although HBO combined with radiotherapy or chemotherapy is reported to improve the clinical efficacy of radiotherapy or chemotherapy for glioma6, there is considerable debate about how HBO alone affects malignant glioma growth. Ding et al.7 and Wang et al.8 both demonstrated that HBO promotes the growth of in situ glioma in mice via mechanisms that involve the inhibition of apoptosis and the promotion of tumor angiogenesis. Under physiological conditions, HBO is reported to promote tumor angiogenesis by inducing oxidative stress9.
However, one study indicated that short-term HBO exposure promotes tumor cell proliferation, whereas prolonged HBO exposure promotes apoptosis and inhibits proliferation10. Therefore, further studies are needed to explore whether HBO promotes or inhibits the growth of glioma and how HBO combined with radiotherapy or chemotherapy can induce therapeutic sensitization. In particular, mechanistic details about how HBO improves the radiosensitivity of glioma are needed. To explore how HBO improves the radiosensitivity of human U251 glioma cells in this study, we used HBO combined with X-ray irradiation on glioma cell proliferation and observed the effects on cell cycle distribution and apoptosis.
All study methods were approved by the Institutional Review Board and Ethics Committee of the Second Hospital Affiliated with Lanzhou University and were performed in accordance with relevant guidelines and regulations.
1. Treatment of glioma cells
NOTE: The U251 glioma cell line was used in this experiment.
2. U251 glioma cells in different groups
3. Radiosensitivity of U251 glioma cells (clone formation assay) within 30 min after HBO
4. Cell counting assay to assess U251 glioma cell proliferation
5. Detection of apoptosis of U251 glioma cells
6. Detection of U251 glioma cell cycle distribution
7. Statistical analysis
Culture of U251 glioma cells
U251 glioma cells had a fusiform shape 24 h to 48 h after culture in DMEM and were adherent. These cells were used for further study (Figure 1).
Glioma cell morphology and count
The cell counts for the U251 glioma cells in the HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) group were significantly lower than that for the X-ray (2 Gy) group after 24 h, 48 h, and 72 h of cell culture (all P < 0.05) (Table 1). When cultured for 24 h, untreated U251 cells in the control group grew well with a long, spindle-shaped morphology. In the X-ray (2 Gy) group, the U251 cell density decreased, with a small number of suspended dead cells visible. In the HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) group, the cell density decreased, and there were more suspended dead cells. When cultured for 48 h, the cell density continuously decreased in the X-ray (2 Gy) and the HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) groups, while the density increased for the control group. When cultured for 72 h, the cell density further decreased in the X-ray (2 Gy) group, particularly the HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) group (Figure 2).
Effects of HBO treatment on the radiosensitivity of U251 glioma cells
The SF decreased dose dependently with increasing radiation dose (0 Gy, 2 Gy, 4 Gy, 6 Gy, and 8 Gy) in the X-ray and HBO combined with X-ray groups. The SF was significantly lower in the HBO combined with X-ray group compared to the X-ray group for all radiation doses tested (all P < 0.05) (Table 2). Together, these results show that HBO treatment increased the radiosensitivity of the U251 glioma cells.
D0, Dq, N, and SF2 were inversely associated with radiosensitivity and were lower in the HBO combined with X-ray group than in the X-ray group for the U251 cells. These results demonstrate that HBO increased the radiosensitivity of the U251 glioma cells (Table 3).
Effects of HBO treatment on radiation-induced inhibition of U251 glioma cell proliferation
With increasing radiation dose (0 Gy, 2 Gy, 4 Gy, 6 Gy, and 8 Gy), the inhibition of the cell proliferation gradually increased for both the X-ray groups and those that received HBO combined with X-ray. The proliferation rate was significantly inhibited for the HBO combined with X-ray group compared to the X-ray-only group at all radiation doses tested (all P < 0.05). These results indicate that HBO enhanced the inhibitory effect of X-ray radiation on the proliferation of U251 glioma cells (Table 4).
Effect of HBO on U251 glioma cell cycle distribution and apoptosis
The percentage of cells in the G2/M phase of the cell cycle was significantly higher for the HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) group (26.70% ± 2.46%) and HBO group (22.36% ± 0.91%) compared to the control group (11.56% ± 2.01%) and X-ray (2 Gy) group (10.35% ± 2.69%) (all P < 0.05). However, there were no significant differences in the percentage of G2/M phase cells between the control group and the X-ray (2 Gy)-only group or between the HBO group and the HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) group (all P > 0.05) (Table 5, Figure 3, and Figure 4). Thus, HBO likely arrested U251 glioma cells in the G2/M phase to promote glioma U251 cell cycle synchronization.
The number of apoptotic U251 cells was significantly higher in the HBO and X-ray (2 Gy) groups than the control group (all P < 0.05) and in the HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) group compared to the HBO, X-ray (2 Gy), and control groups (all P < 0.05) (Figure 5 and Table 5). From the above results, both HBO and X-ray appeared to induce U251 cell apoptosis, but the ability of HBO combined with X-ray to induce apoptosis of U251 cells was more pronounced.
Figure 1: Glioma U251 cell morphology. (A) U251 cells (20x); (B) glioma U251 cells (100x). Scale bar = 10 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Morphology of cells in the different groups 24 h, 48 h, and 72 h after cell culture. Control group, 20x; HBO combined with X-ray, 20x; X-ray (2 Gy), 20x; HBO group, 100x. Abbreviations: HBO = hyperbaric oxygen. Scale bar = 10 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Glioma U251 cell cycle distribution in each group (n = 3). Abbreviation: HBO = hyperbaric oxygen. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Glioma U251 cell cycle distribution in each group (n = 3). (A) HBO group; (B) X-ray (2 Gy) group; (C) HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) group; (D) Control group. Abbreviations: HBO = hyperbaric oxygen; PE-A = phycoerythrin-peak area. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: U251 glioma cell apoptosis in each group (n = 3). (A) X-ray (2 Gy) group; (B) Control group; (C) HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) group; (D) HBO group. Abbreviations: HBO = hyperbaric oxygen; PE-A = phycoerythrin-peak area; FITC-A = fluorescein isothiocyanate-peak area. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
(x̄ ± s) (n=3) × 106 | |||
Groups | 24 h | 48 h | 72 h |
Control group | 2.03±0.17 | 3.27±0.21 | 5.94±0.16 |
HBO combined with X-ray | 1.04±0.13 | 0.36±0.06 | 0.08±0.04 |
X-ray | 1.94±0.09 | 0.79±0.09 | 0.43±0.10 |
HBO | 2.34±0.10 | 3.50±0.12 | 6.00±0.15 |
P | 0.017 | 0.03 | 0.013 |
Table 1: U251 cell count for each group. Cell counts are 1 × 106. P is for HBO combined with X-ray (2 Gy) versus X-ray (2 Gy). Abbreviation: HBO = hyperbaric oxygen.
(x̄ ± s) (n=3) | |||||
Groups | 0 Gy | 2 Gy | 4 Gy | 6 Gy | 8 Gy |
X-ray | 1 | 0.66 | 0.424 | 0.301 | 0.075 |
HBO combined with X-ray | 0.75 | 0.319 | 0.235 | 0.109 | 0.019 |
P | 0.019 | 0.019 | 0.031 | 0.04 | 0.036 |
Table 2: U251 cell survival fraction for each group. Abbreviation: HBO = hyperbaric oxygen.
(n=3) | ||||||
Items | D0 (Gy) | Dq (Gy) | N | SF2 | SER (D0) | SER (Dq) |
Groups | ||||||
X-ray | 4.01 | 2.305 | 1.314 | 0.66 | ---- ---- | ---- ---- |
HBO combined with X-ray | 2.64 | 1.143 | 0.436 | 0.319 | 1.52 | 2.02 |
Table 3: Radiobiological parameters of U251 cells in the X-ray and HBO combined with X-ray groups. n = 3. Abbreviations: HBO = hyperbaric oxygen; D0 = mean lethal dose; Dq = quasi-threshold dose; N = extrapolation number; SF2 = survival fraction at an irradiation dose of 2 Gy; SER = sensitization enhancement ratio; SER (D0) = D0 in the control group/D0 in the experimental group; SER (Dq) = Dq in the control group/Dq in the experimental group.
(n=5) | |||||
Groups | 0 Gy | 2 Gy | 4 Gy | 6 Gy | 8 Gy |
X-ray | 0 | 0.1026 | 0.153 | 0.2157 | 0.2327 |
HBO combined with X-ray | 0.0189 | 0.2039 | 0.2622 | 0.3143 | 0.336 |
P | 0.045 | 0.018 | 0.026 | 0.02 | 0.015 |
Table 4: Inhibition of proliferation of U251 glioma cells in each group. n = 5. Abbreviation: HBO = hyperbaric oxygen.
Cycles | G1/G0 | S | G2/M | Apoptosis |
Groups | ||||
HBO | 59.23±1.46 | 18.41±0.54 | 22.36±0.91*# | 10.25±4.48*& |
X-ray | 74.77±4.14 | 14.89±1.45* | 10.35±2.69 | 12.31±5.39*& |
HBO combined with X-ray | 53.60±3.23 | 19.72±0.76 | 26.70±2.46*# | 28.89±8.78* |
Control | 67.96±2.41 | 20.49±0.40 | 11.56±2.01 | 5.21±2.03& |
Table 5: Cell cycle distribution and apoptosis of U251 cells in each group. n = 3, %. Abbreviations: HBO = hyperbaric oxygen. * indicates P < 0.05 as compared with the control group. # indicates P < 0.05 as compared with the X-ray group. & indicates P < 0.05 as compared with HBO combined with X-ray.
The glioma cell line U251 is one of the most classical human glioma cell lines and is widely used as a glioma model in many studies.
Effects of HBO on U251 glioma cell proliferation
HBO typically refers to breathing pure oxygen (100% oxygen concentration) in a sealed chamber with a pressure 1.5-3-fold higher than normal atmospheric pressure, which can increase oxygen content in microvascular plasma14. For patients with glioma, combining radiotherapy or chemotherapy with HBO is reported to increase the clinical efficacy of these treatments. In children or young adults with central nervous system neoplasms, HBO combined with radiotherapy can improve clinical symptoms and tumor imaging results. Although the application of HBO is safe6, there is considerable debate about the effects of HBO alone on malignant glioma growth. Ding et al.7 showed that HBO inhibited apoptosis and increased microvascular density in tumor tissues by promoting the expression of vascular endothelial growth factor and hypoxia-inducible factor-1a, suggesting that pure HBO would not be beneficial for the treatment of glioma. HBO was reported to promote glioma cell growth in a rat model of glioma8 and promote tumor angiogenesis by inducing oxidative stress under physiological conditions9. Short-term exposure to HBO promotes tumor cell proliferation, whereas prolonged exposure inhibits tumor cell proliferation10. HBO inhibits apoptosis and reduces tumor microvessel density in subcutaneously transplanted gliomas; however, these effects are not seen in intracranial transplanted glioma15,16. This study showed that the inhibition of cell proliferation rate was significantly higher for the HBO combined with X-ray group than for the X-ray group at each dose (all P < 0.05), as well as for the HBO group compared to the control group (P < 0.05). This result suggests that HBO can enhance the inhibitory effect of X-rays on U251 glioma cell proliferation and that HBO alone does not promote the proliferation of these glioma cells. The effect of HBO on tumor growth may be associated with a variety of factors, such as tumor site and differentiation status, as well as HBO pressure and HBO duration. In this study, HBO at 0.2 MPa (2.0 ATA) was used for 90 min, and the HBO treatment was repeated three times. The relationships of HBO duration, frequency, and pressure with U251 glioma cell proliferation will require further investigation. These results indicated that, with increasing radiation dose (0 Gy, 2 Gy, 4 Gy, 6 Gy, and 8 Gy), the inhibition of cell proliferation gradually increased in the X-ray groups and HBO combined with X-ray groups, and the proliferation rate was significantly lower for the HBO combined with X-ray group than for the X-ray group for each radiation dose. This result demonstrates that HBO can enhance the inhibitory effect of X-rays on the proliferation of U251 glioma cells.
Radiotherapy can produce reactive oxygen species (ROS) that cause DNA damage in tumor cells. However, hypoxia in tumor tissues directly reduces ROS production, which can decrease the therapeutic effect of radiotherapy on tumor cells. In the anoxic microenvironment, tumor cells are likely to bind to hydrogen atoms from sulfhydryl compounds, and this binding neutralizes the free radicals generated by ionizing radiation and decreases tumor cell DNA injury. However, in an oxygen-enriched environment, the free radicals generated by ionizing radiation are rapidly oxidized and capable of damaging tumor cell DNA. This may be the potential mechanism by which HBO can enhance the inhibitory effect of X-rays on U251 glioma cell proliferation.
The effect of HBO on U251 glioma cell radiosensitivity
A clone formation assay is simple and suitable for adherent cells. The preparation of cell suspensions and the inoculation density are important for this assay. The cells must be well dispersed without cell clusters, and the inoculation density should not be too high. The limitation of this clone formation assay is that only adherent cells can be investigated for the effects of HBO on proliferation.
In this study, the SF was significantly lower for the HBO group (0.750 ± 0.023) than the control group (1.000 ± 0.000) (P = 0.019), demonstrating that HBO does not promote U251 glioma cell growth. This result is consistent with those for the cell counting assay. With increasing radiation dose (0 Gy, 2 Gy, 4 Gy, 6 Gy, and 8 Gy), the SF gradually decreased and was significantly lower for the HBO combined with X-ray group than for the X-ray group at each radiation dose (all P < 0.05), demonstrating that the radiosensitivity of U251 glioma cells increased after HBO treatment. In addition, the survival curves for the U251 glioma cells, as well as all the radiobiological parameters, indicated that SF2, D0, and Dq were significantly lower for the HBO combined with X-ray group than for the X-ray group, suggesting that HBO can improve the radiosensitivity of glioma cells. SF2 is reported to be closely related to the post-radiotherapy 2 year tumor survival rate, local control rate, and recurrence rate17,18,19.
The effects of HBO on the U251 glioma cell cycle and apoptosis
DNA characteristics vary among the phases of the cell cycle. For example, cellular DNA is 2N in the G0/G1 phase and 4N in the G2/M phase. Propidium iodide (PI) can bind to DNA, and the fluorescence intensity of the complex directly reflects the intracellular DNA status. Therefore, flow cytometry and PI staining can be used to detect the cell cycle. The key to this experimental technology is an increase in the permeability of the cellular membranes that reduces cell adhesion. In cells treated with ethanol, Triton X-100, and EDTA, the final concentration of PI must reach 50 µg/mL to allow for accurate detection of the cell cycle distribution.
The cell cycle comprises G0/G1, S, and G2/M phases, which play an important role in regulating tumor cell growth. The G0/G1 phase is the preparatory stage of DNA synthesis or the initial stage of cell proliferation, whereas the S phase is the active stage of cell proliferation in which DNA replication is completed. The G2/M phase is the stage in which genetic material is distributed and new daughter cells form. Any factor that blocks a particular phase of the cell cycle can induce cellular synchronization and, in turn, a relative increase in the proportion of cells in a certain phase20. Cells in different cell cycle phases have different radiosensitivity. For example, cells in early G1 phase exhibit radioantagonism, whereas cells in the G1/S phase have slightly elevated radiosensitivity. Cells in the S phase have a moderate elevation of radiosensitivity, and G2/M phase cells have the highest radiosensitivity. This study showed that the percentage of G2/M phase cells was significantly higher in the HBO combined with X-ray group than in the X-ray and control groups. However, there was no significant difference in the percentage of G2/M phase cells between the HBO and HBO combined with X-ray groups, suggesting that HBO can cause U251 glioma cells to arrest in the G2/M phase. This conclusion is consistent with the findings reported by Kalns and Piepmeier21. Therefore, cell cycle synchronization in the G2/M phase not only inhibits tumor cell proliferation but also increases the sensitivity of tumor cells to radiotherapy.
Apoptosis plays an important role in human embryo development, tissue repair, and internal environment stabilization. This study showed that the apoptosis of U251 cells was significantly higher for the HBO and X-ray groups than the control group, as well as for the HBO combined with X-ray group compared to the HBO, X-ray, and control groups, suggesting that HBO and X-ray together may induce U251 cell apoptosis and that HBO can enhance X-ray-induced apoptosis. Apoptosis is closely related to tumor growth and development. X-ray and HBO are both reported to induce tumor cell apoptosis10,15,16, which is consistent with the results of this study. HBO may promote apoptosis by regulating the expression of apoptosis-related genes such as aspartate protein hydrolase (caspase), B-cell lymphoma-2 (Bcl-2), and B-lymphoma (Bax)22. The Bcl-2 gene family proteins play an important role in regulating tumor radiosensitivity. For example, increased Bcl-2 gene expression can antagonize radiation-induced apoptosis, while Bax gene overexpression can enhance tumor radiosensitivity23,24. HBO can improve tumor radiosensitivity by downregulating Bcl-2 and Bcl-xl expression while upregulating that of Bax25,26.
In summary, HBO may be used to treat glioma because it can enhance the apoptosis, proliferation inhibition, and radiosensitivity of U251 glioma cells by blocking the cells in the G2/M phase. However, further study is needed to characterize in detail the molecular mechanisms involved in the ability of HBO to enhance glioma cell radiosensitivity and to induce apoptosis.
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
None.
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
Binding Buffer | Dickinson and Company | RH10 9RR | |
CCK-8 test kit | DOJINDO | NJ | Cell counting assay |
CELL FIT | cell cycle analysis (DNA content) | ||
CELLQUEST | apoptotic cell analysis | ||
DMEM and Annexin V-FITC | Gibco BRL | ||
flow cytometer | Dickinson | ||
Glioma U251 and U87 cell line | Shanghai Institute of Cell Biology | ||
hyperbaric oxygen chamber | Hongyuan Institute | ||
medical linear accelerator | Elekta Limited Company | ||
microplate reader | |||
MOD FITLT formac v1.01 | cell analysis--cell cycle phase | ||
trypsin | Hyclone Laboratories Inc |
Request permission to reuse the text or figures of this JoVE article
Request PermissionThis article has been published
Video Coming Soon
Copyright © 2025 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved